Dissertation Project: Negotiating Scientific Evidence
LMU Munich, Winter semester of 2021- on going
Faculty of Public Health
Airlangga University
LMU Munich, Winter semester of 2021- on going
My dissertation is titled Negotiating Science Evidence: Scientist–Journalist Relations and Knowledge Mediation in Indonesia’s Pandemic Science Communication. I have been working on it at the Institut für Kommunikationswissenschaft und Medienforschung (IfKW), Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, since the winter semester of 2021. My primary advisor is Prof. Dr. Thomas Hanitzsch, and my secondary advisor is Prof. Dr. Constanze Rossmann.
This research stems from the experience of the COVID-19 pandemic in Indonesia. At that time, scientific evidence was changing rapidly, uncertainty was high, and the public demanded immediate answers. I was interested in one question: how do scientists and journalists work together to determine what constitutes knowledge worthy of being communicated to the public? Science communication studies have traditionally tended to view the relationship between the two as a one-way flow, from the knowledgeable scientist to the journalist who conveys the message. I wanted to demonstrate that this relationship is better understood as a negotiation.
I chose The Conversation Indonesia as my case study. On this platform, scientists write and journalists edit as part of a collaborative process. I treat it as a space where the relationship between scientists and journalists actually takes place, rather than as a sample representative of all science journalism in Indonesia. I interviewed 6 journalists and 20 scientists using the retrospective reconstruction interview method. Each interview was grounded in an article they had previously worked on together, allowing participants to recall the specific decisions behind each piece. I analyzed this data using reflective thematic analysis.
My theoretical framework is based on three concepts. Drawing from postnormal science theory, I adopt the understanding that in a crisis, uncertain facts, contested values, and urgent decisions coexist. From the concept of boundary work, I examine how each party draws lines between science and non-science, as well as between the roles of scientists and journalists. Drawing on relational sociology, I argue that the roles of both parties are not inherent to individuals; rather, these roles materialize within specific work situations. I situate all three within the context of mediatization and platformization. Within this context, I propose the concept of epistemic compression under algorithmic pressure—that is, the simplification of scientific knowledge driven by the logic of visibility on digital platforms.
The main finding of this research is a typology of six forms of relationships between scientists and journalists: transmission, symbiosis, conflict, negotiation, accountability, and epistemic convergence. This typology demonstrates that a given scientist-journalist pair can shift from one form of relationship to another, depending on the issue, time constraints, and the level of uncertainty they face.
I wrote this dissertation from the perspective of a researcher from the Global South. This perspective has made me critical of the deficit model and the Eurocentric frameworks that have long dominated this field of study. Parts of this argument have been published in Observatorio (OBS*), in the form of a proposal for two-way reflexivity between science and journalism. Through this research, I hope to contribute to an understanding of how scientific evidence can be communicated more honestly and equitably, especially when the public needs it most.
Separuh klaim riset sosial dan perilaku tidak bertahan ketika dicoba ulang
Ilham Akhsanu Ridlo, Rizqy Amelia Zein
2026 Sep 30
Can science and journalism be mutually reflexive? A Global South perspective
Ilham Akhsanu Ridlo
Observatorio (OBS*), vol. 20(2), 2026 Jun
Post-publication review: the role of science news outlets and social media
Dasapta Erwin Irawan, Olivier Pourret, Lonni Besançon, Sandy Hardian Susanto Herho, Ilham Akhsanu Ridlo, Juneman Abraham
Annals of Library and Information Studies , 71 (4), 2024
What is the role of journalism in the political advocacy of health policy in Indonesia?
Ilham Akhsanu Ridlo
Jurnal Administrasi Kesehatan Indonesia, vol. 12(1), 2024
Frequency and specificity of health issues in local political campaigns
Ilham Akhsanu Ridlo
International Journal of Health Governance, vol. 28(4), 2023
Ilham Akhsanu Ridlo
2022 Aug 25
How Does Islamic Organizations Respond to COVID-19 in Indonesia? A Case Study
Aisyah Putri Rahvy, Ilham Akhsanu Ridlo
Public Health and Preventive Medicine Archives, 2021